Kim Yeon-su Advocates 100% Mandatory Tender Offer to Resolve Korea Stocks Discount

Key Takeaways

  • Kim Yeon-su, CEO of Kansas Asset Management, advocated for a 100% mandatory tender offer in an interview on the 16th.
  • Kim Yeon-su stated that South Korean M&A deals occur at approximately 14 times EBITDA compared to 7 times in the stock market.
  • Kim Yeon-su criticized the 50%+1 threshold in the Capital Markets Act amendment passed by the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee.

Kim Yeon-su, CEO of Kansas Asset Management, stated in an interview on the 16th that South Korea's proposed mandatory tender offer system should require 100% acquisition of shares rather than the 50%+1 threshold currently outlined in a bill pending before the National Assembly. The interview followed a capital market policy meeting on the 13th chaired by President Lee Jae-myung, where the tender offer ratio became a point of contention. Kim argued that a 50%+1 structure would fail to resolve the Korea discount because it allows acquirers to maintain listing status while holding majority control, leaving minority shareholders without access to M&A-level valuations. His position draws on over 20 years of experience arranging acquisition financing for major M&A deals at LG Investment & Securities and NH Investment & Securities, including transactions for Han & Company, MBK Partners, Hanon Systems, SK Shipping, and JobKorea. The debate centers on whether stricter tender offer requirements can align stock market valuations with M&A transaction prices, a gap Kim identifies as the core of South Korea's equity market undervaluation.

Kim Yeon-su Cites EV/EBITDA Valuation Gap Between M&A and Stock Markets

Kim Yeon-su identified the valuation gap between South Korea's M&A transaction market and listed stock market as the root cause of the Korea discount. He explained that US companies trade at approximately 15 times EBITDA in M&A transactions and approximately 14 times in the stock market, showing minimal discrepancy. In contrast, South Korean M&A transactions occur at approximately 14 times EBITDA while the listed stock market trades at only 7 times EBITDA. Kim stated that the same company receives completely different valuations depending on whether it is traded in the M&A market or the stock market. He argued that a 100% mandatory tender offer would allow all shareholders to sell at M&A transaction prices, and this expectation would be reflected in ordinary share prices. Kim claimed that if the stock market's valuation multiple rose from 7 times to the M&A market level of 14 times, the market would double in value by simple calculation.

Kim Yeon-su Criticizes 50%+1 Tender Offer Threshold for Creating Entrenched Shareholders

Kim Yeon-su stated that the Capital Markets Act amendment currently passed by the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee requires acquirers to secure 50%+1 shares of total issued shares when acquiring management rights of a listed company. He criticized this approach for creating listed companies with majority shareholders who remain immune to market discipline. Kim stated that when a controlling shareholder holds a majority stake, market checks effectively do not function, and it is contradictory for such companies to remain listed. He argued that the 50%+1 tender offer structure is worse than not introducing the system at all, because it produces listed companies where shareholder oversight cannot operate. Kim emphasized that acquirers seeking management control should purchase 100% of shares and delist the company.

Kim Yeon-su Rebuts M&A Contraction Concerns by Citing Harmful Zero-Capital Deals

Kim Yeon-su addressed concerns that 100% mandatory tender offers would contract the M&A market by increasing acquirers' funding burdens. He stated that frequent M&A activity can harm the stability of business partners and employees and negatively affect corporate value. Kim cited past cases in the KOSDAQ market where acquirers with insufficient funding relied on borrowed money or the target company's assets to secure management rights, then damaged corporate value. He argued that raising the mandatory tender offer ratio would filter out inadequate acquirers and restructure the M&A market around acquirers with sufficient funding and management capability. Kim stated that increased funding burden creates an entry barrier that can eliminate harmful zero-capital and low-capital M&A deals that have muddied the KOSDAQ market, describing this as a positive effect rather than a negative contraction.

Kim Yeon-su Proposes Private-Sector Stabilization Fund for Volatility Management

Kim Yeon-su commented on market flows following President Lee Jae-myung's capital market meeting held the previous week. He stated that the stock market initially showed a firm tone at the meeting's start but turned lower by the close, reflecting disappointment that no measures to manage volatility emerged. Kim identified the securities market stabilization fund as a core volatility management tool. He stated that the fund, which operates under government leadership during crises such as the financial crisis or COVID-19, should now transition to a private-sector permanent program because it uses financial institutions' funds. Kim stated that the fund's activation conditions previously focused on the causes of volatility, but now managing volatility itself has become important. He stated that the design should be refined so the fund activates when volatility exceeds a certain level.

FAQ

What did Kim Yeon-su propose regarding South Korea's mandatory tender offer system on the 16th?

Kim Yeon-su proposed that South Korea's mandatory tender offer system should require 100% acquisition of shares rather than the 50%+1 threshold outlined in the National Assembly bill. He argued that a 50%+1 structure would fail to resolve the Korea discount because it allows acquirers to maintain listing status while holding majority control, leaving minority shareholders without access to M&A-level valuations.

Why does Kim Yeon-su argue that 100% mandatory tender offers would resolve the Korea discount?

Kim Yeon-su stated that South Korean M&A transactions occur at approximately 14 times EBITDA while the listed stock market trades at only 7 times EBITDA. He argued that a 100% mandatory tender offer would allow all shareholders to sell at M&A transaction prices, and this expectation would be reflected in ordinary share prices, potentially doubling the market's valuation multiple from 7 times to 14 times.

How does Kim Yeon-su respond to concerns that 100% mandatory tender offers would contract the M&A market?

Kim Yeon-su stated that raising the mandatory tender offer ratio would filter out inadequate acquirers and eliminate harmful zero-capital and low-capital M&A deals that have muddied the KOSDAQ market. He argued that increased funding burden creates an entry barrier that restructures the M&A market around acquirers with sufficient funding and management capability, describing this as a positive effect rather than a negative contraction.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or encourage the buying or selling of crypto assets. It is intended to provide information about industry developments and is not directly related to the services offered by Gate TR. Although information obtained from third-party sources has been carefully reviewed, Gate TR assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. Crypto assets involve high risks and may experience significant price fluctuations. Before making any investment decisions, you should assess your financial situation and risk tolerance, conduct your own research, and make decisions independently.